Friday, February 6, 1998

Session I (571-5)

Session II (553-6)

3:45 - 4:15 Mandie Aaron

Historical uses of technology

Jennifer Desroches

The satellite industry in Canada

 

Historical uses of technology
Mandie Aaron

Introducing, implementing and ultimately integrating technology into the classroom is not a new phenomenon. From slate to radio to the overhead projector to the multi-media computer platform, various technologies have been introduced into the classroom environment to varying degrees of success and failure. It is not sufficient to have the equipment in the classroom -- productive use must be made of that equipment for it to have any effect. The best of intentions are one thing -- actual use another. What is it, for example, that compels one teacher to use the equipment in all facets of her day and another to let it collect dust in the corner? Is it the teacher's attitude? Motivation? Support system?

The use of television in the classroom, for example, was looked upon with promise yet, for the most part, failed to live up to the expectations that were placed upon it (Coltman, 1994; Strommen, 1995). We are currently undergoing another technological revolution (Ohler, 1995; Owston, 1997) -- nevertheless, in some instances, that too has not been as successful as previously hyped and hoped (Graham, 1997; Wallis, 1995). Researching the body of work written about past attempts at the implementation and integration of technology will provide valuable insight into the current phenomenon of technological use and integration.

In order to gain insight into the practice of educational integration of technology, I will be conducting historical research into different bodies of literature. Firstly, examining historical uses of technology in education will allow for the determination of best and worst practices. Identifying the elements that are present (or absent) when technology is successfully implemented and the elements that are absent (or present) when this implementation fails is an important step in securing future integration success. By investigating how technology has been used in the past, parallels can be drawn and recommendations made for current purposes.

Literature relating to the history of technology as well as that of adapting to change will also be examined. An element of this literature which is particularly intriguing is that of the social shaping and cultural elements of technological use (Ellul, 1964; Feenberg, 1991; Mumford, 1934; Williams, 1997). For any technology to be accepted in to a society, there needs to be certain cultural and social elements in place or the technology will not gain a stronghold. Can this same notion of culture be applied in the educational setting? Should we be looking at the cultural and social climate of a given educational environment before even attempting to introduce a new technology? Understanding how people look at technology can certainly help to ensure successful use and integration of technology.

During this roundtable discussion I plan to present several ideas regarding the social-shaping and cultural aspects of technology as outlined in the previous paragraph. I invite participants to draw upon their expertise and critique these notions with an eye towards their practicability. Is it even feasible, for example, to draw parallels between society's use of technology and classroom use? Ultimately, I would like this roundtable discussion to help concretize and focus the questions to be addressed in my research.

 

Coltman, P.(1994).Seduction by technology:Promises of a whore.Journal of Educational Television, 20 (3), 185-192.

Ellul, J.(1964).The technological society.New York:Vintage Books.

Feenberg, A.(1991).Critical theory of technology.New York:Oxford University Press.

Graham, D. R.(1997, Spring).The classroom computer revolution that hasn't happened -- Yet!Education Canada, 10-15.

Mumford, L.(1934).Technics and civilization.New York:Harcourt, Brace and Company.

Ohler, J.(1996).The 4 Rs.Technos, 5 (2), 26-27.

Owston, R. D.(1997, March).The world wide web:A technology to enhance teaching and learning?Educational Researcher, 27-33.

Strommen, E.(1995, November/December).Television catches its second wave.Electronic Learning, 30-37, 57.

Wallis, C.(1995, Spring).The learning revolution.Time, 145~(12), 49-51.

Williams, R.(1997).The social shaping of information and communications technologies.In H. Kubicek, W. H. Dutton, & R. Williams (Eds.),The social shaping of information superhighways(pp. 299-338).Frankfurt, Germany: Campus Verlag.

 

The satellite industry in Canada
Jennifer Desroches

The satellite industry in Canada

My topic is not that of a research project but rather a subject of interest, that being the satellite industry in Canada. In particular I will examine how various Canadian corporations are utilizing this technology for training and the dissemination of information. Canada's corporations must keep their employees abreast of relevant information wherever and whenever possible in an attempt to remain competitive. I will present examples which demonstrate that training is no longer confined to the classroom. In doing so, I will consider such questions as : What are the benefits and disadvantages to this technology? And, is it being utilized to its full potential?

The presentation will briefly cover the technical details of satellite communication as well as its historical evolution in Canada. However, this is not the essence of my presentation. It is simply an introductory section since this information may prove useful to the participants understanding throughout. As mentioned above, the core of the presentation considers the use and helpfulness of satellites for education in the corporate marketplace in Canada. However, time permitting, I will also discuss its utilization in other sectors such as education and government.